P.S. Kitchen, 246 W. 48th St., New York, NY
Hours: 11 a.m.-11 p.m. Wednesday-Saturday; 11 a.m.-10 p.m. Sunday-Tuesday.
Menu: https://www.ps-kitchen.com/brunch
Suitable for: Vegetarians, vegans, omnivores, theater-goers
When we find ourselves in New York City – which, happily, usually ends up being three or four times each year – we try very hard to keep our dining options open. In a city with approximately 40 zillion vegetarian-friendly restaurants, it feels a bit of a crime to keep returning to the same place over and over and over again.
But with P.S. Kitchen, we’ll make an exception to that rule. Even on trips when we don’t intend to visit the restaurant on ()th Street, we somehow find ourselves back there anyway, via a reservation that’s fallen through or the proximity to a show we’re seeing after dinner. But this, I can attest, is not a hardship. In fact, it is a joy.
I’d had my eye on P.S. Kitchen since early in 2020, when we’d planned on visiting much later in the year for Christmas. Alas, we all know what happened throughout the year, and thus it took me a bit longer than planned to finally darken the doorstep. But since then, we’ve made up for lost time!
And about that doorstep: Blink and you’ll miss it. I can’t tell you the number of times I’ve walked right by and had to double back! But once you enter the restaurant, you’re transported to an oasis of calm-and-chic comfort. Wearing jeans? Dressed in your Broadway finery (pro tip: tell the waitstaff if you have a show to go to)? Either way, you’ll feel comfortable. The staff will see to it!
Now, before we get to the food, a word about the restaurant’s mission. A full 100% of its profits go to P.S. Kitchen’s charitable partners, which as of this writing include Share Hope, Justice Rising, Restore and Defy Ventures. A restaurant that walks the walk and serves great food? Where do I sign up?
Speaking of that great food: There’s no shortage of it here. Every item on the menu that we’ve tried so far is a winner, from shareables through main courses through dessert. Our go-to plan is to order entrees and then splurge on dessert, but you’d do just as well swapping in an appetizer. And if you drink alcoholic beverages, have a gander at their cocktail and wine lists; we’ve not had a drink yet that hasn’t been out of this world. (Looking for a mocktail? The restaurant’s zero-proof options are plentiful as well!)
On our most recent visit to P.S. Kitchen, I had my wintertime favorite: Chik’n pot pie. While I try to diversify my order, my heart always comes back to the pot pie in the end; I can’t seem to go more than two visits without having it! LeeLee joined in the fun this time, surprising me by also ordering a pot pie, though on other visits he’s enjoyed the kitchen’s various burgers and pasta dishes with great success.
We finished off our meal with a panna cotta, which was both light and decadent at once. It was another of those dishes where I wished it were socially appropriate to lick the plate after the fact; we didn’t want to let one molecule go to waste!
We tottered out of P.S. Kitchen a little more than an hour after we’d arrived, enjoying a wonderful dinner before continuing our stroll toward the Lincoln Center for an evening performance. But oh, I wished we’d had time for an after-dinner coffee or something a bit stronger! That will just give us something to look forward to next time, I suppose!
:)